OVERLORD D-Day & the Battle for Normandy BY Max Hastings

Post any off-topic thread you wish.

Moderator: Scub

User avatar
pfclt
Member
Member
Posts: 1052
Joined: Sat Mar 26, 2011 4:35 am
Location: In my attic - in another world - looking

OVERLORD D-Day & the Battle for Normandy BY Max Hastings

Unread post by pfclt » Sun Jul 13, 2014 10:10 pm

This is another good book covering the event of the invasion of Europe. A lot of the same material but some stuff I don’t recall hearing before:

The first quote makes one question?? What was the Russian numbers?
Pg. 35.
“Each American soldier in Normandy received six and a quarter pounds of rations a day, against three and a third pounds for his German enemy……. German small-arms ammunition scale for a rifle company was more than double that of its American equivalent, 56000 rounds to 21000”
I think the first part of the following may be open to debate and I also think we all know or at least probably agree the second part of the following is also probably accurate?
Pg. 185.
German leadership at corps level and above was often little better than that of the Allies, and sometimes worse. But at regimental level and below, it was superb. The German army appeared to have access to a bottomless reservoir of brave, able and quick-thinking colonels commanding battle-groups and of NCOs capable of directing the defence of an entire sector of the front.
Pg. 187.
American research showed that, in many regiments, only 15 per cent of riflemen used their weapons in any given action
Pg.188.
“The Germans ….. mortar “stonks” ….. responsible for an extraordinary high proportion of casualties -75% …… The Allies ….. never mastered the art of concentrating them……

the excellent Panzerfaust, the finest infantry anti-tank weapon of the war. Gavin’s paratroopers seized and employed as many as they could capture.
And many more quotes could be made.

This book like most starts with pre-invasion history ending with the Falaise gap. There is a section called casualties - gives a clear picture of the extent of its impact. Also Hastings is more Montgomery friendly than others I have read it is hard to determine whom is more objective on the subject though I am inclined to fall into the non Montgomery group - Hastings does make me have a little sympathy to his contribution.
Image

User avatar
FieldMarshall Ober
Founder
Founder
Posts: 5070
Joined: Tue Mar 22, 2011 7:37 pm
Location: OK, Its late july and summer is over in Canada....it was 3 days this year!
Contact:

Re: OVERLORD D-Day & the Battle for Normandy BY Max Hastings

Unread post by FieldMarshall Ober » Mon Jul 14, 2014 1:38 pm

Great book. I studied it in college many years ago while taking some war studies electives. It was the text book for the course, quite detailed and accurate. So much classified information has been released in recent years my feeling is that some areas could be a bit dated. The professor was a man named Mark Milne who is an authority on the battle of the Atlantic, and has a number of good books published on the subject.
"Maybe there are 5,000, maybe 10,000 Nazi bastards in their concrete foxholes before the Third Army. Now if Ike stops holding Monty's hand and gives me some supplies, I'll go through the Siegfried Line like %*$# through a goose."
~Gen. G.S. Patton

Image

Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests